ANNOUNCEMENT: Expert Investor is now PA Europe. Read more.

Are ESG funds doomed to fail under Trump?

President-elect Donald Trump might not be all bad for funds that make impactful investments in clean energy, technology or innovative pharmaceuticals, says AXA Investment Managers global head of responsible investment Matt Christensen.

Trying to elucidate any one of Trump’s policies before the election has been an exercise in reading between the tea leaves.

One policy he has been clearer and slightly more consistent on is energy. Trump’s statement on energy independence, published to his administration’s transitionary website, includes avowals that he will “end the war on coal,” “rescind the coal mining lease moratorium” and “conduct a top-down review of all anti-coal regulations issued by the Obama Administration.”

Trump, who has called man-made climate change a hoax, also promises to scrap Obama’s Climate Action Plan and the Clean Power Plan and “refocus,” (i.e. dismantle) the Environmental Protection Agency.

Big pharma stocks, oil and gas giants and mining companies were some of the biggest winners the day after the election.

Shares in the world’s largest privately owned coal company, Peabody Energy, spiked by 58.5% to $13.55 mid-morning on Wednesday. Days later, the shares continue to climb, currently up 15.53% at $14.80 per share. Meanwhile, BP, Chevron and Exxon Mobil were also trading upward.

So, what does this mean for the future of responsible investment? By virtue of their ethical mandates, many of these funds exclude the very companies that have benefited in the immediate aftermath of Trump’s victory because of their low environmental, social and governance scores. Will they be able to remain competitive in this environment?

While AXA’s Christensen believes Trump may deliver on his “red meat revival” of the mining and fossil fuel industry, allocating subsidies to the sector, there could be one thing standing in his way – the fear of failure.

Judging from worldwide trends around coal, the industry is not currently considered profitable in the long-term, Christensen argued. Because a yardstick to measure the degree of Trump’s ‘winning’ would obviously include economic success, he may have to live up to the harsh reality that the world is moving away from fossil fuel to remain profitable, he added.

“Trump is a man who likes to win above all else. If winning and revitalising the coal industry do not look compatible, he will not pursue that route,” Christensen speculated.

Should Trump revive these traditional energy industries without pushing for innovation on the energy efficiency front, the US will find itself looking less competitive than the rest of the world.

The ESG investment industry in the UK alone is worth trillions of pounds. And Christensen said the US and Australia are currently the fastest growing markets for ESG and responsible investments. Therefore, by choosing to ignore this bourgeoning trend, Trump is putting the US at a serious disadvantage, Christensen asserted. 

“If he doesn’t stress that businesses need to address the carbon footprint of automotives, for instance, it will become more difficult to sell those products in markets that have higher clean energy standards and have access to more energy efficient vehicles. I think he’d struggle with that even in China.”

That is why under Trump, Christensen expects to see more innovation at the state level and within the private sector.

Ethical funds that strategically invest in companies that prioritise sustainability and ESG factors in traditionally ‘sinful’ areas might be in for a serious boon as well. Christensen noted that pharmaceutical company Novo Nordisk, praised for its sustainability practices, shot up with the rest of the more ethically questionable big pharma stocks on Wednesday.

Despite the uncertain of ESG investing under Trump, Christensen remains confident that come what may, responsible investing will not cease to exist. The industry has moved from “niche to norm” and not even a Trump presidency will change that.



  • Can M&A and buybacks breathe life into UK market?

    Can M&A and buybacks breathe life into UK market?

    Both buybacks and M&A should help realise value in UK shares, boosting prices and giving investors another reason to consider the UK stockmarket Not only does M&A activity appear to be picking up, with a high-profile bid for UK electronics retailer Currys, but the scale of company buybacks continues to accelerate. If it goes well,…

  • Capital Group launches multi-thematic Article 8 funds

    Capital Group launches multi-thematic Article 8 funds

    Capital Group has launched a set of multi-thematic sustainable funds that are available for investors in Europe, writes Christian Mayes. The Capital Group Sustainable Global Opportunities fund (LUX) will invest in global equities, while the Capital Group Sustainable Global Corporate Bond fund (LUX) will target fixed income exposure. The launch also includes a multi-asset offering…

  • Bond funds pull in €29.7bn in January – LSEG

    Bond funds pull in €29.7bn in January – LSEG

    Bond products were the best-selling asset class in January, according to LSEG Lipper’s European Fund Flow report, writes Christian Mayes. The asset class pulled in a net €29.7bn in the month, while Money Market USD grouping was the best-selling Lipper Classification after receiving €11.2bn inflows. Providers of mutual funds pulled in €22.5bn, while passives saw net…

  • Quarter of Article 8 funds at risk of greenwashing – MainStreet Partners

    Quarter of Article 8 funds at risk of greenwashing – MainStreet Partners

    A quarter of all Article 8 funds could be accused of greenwashing based on their sustainability framework and practices, according to MainStreet Partners, writes Christian Mayes The 24% of funds classified as a greenwashing risk by the 2024 ESG Barometer report marks a four percentage point increase from the 20% flagged at the end of…

  • EU green rules could stymie decarbonisation projects – ExxonMobil

    EU green rules could stymie decarbonisation projects – ExxonMobil

    The European Union’s climate regulations may lead to it halting its investments in Europe, ExxonMobil has warned. Speaking to the Financial Times, Karen McKee, president of the product solutions division, said the oil and gas giant had struggled to begin decarbonisation projects in Europe due to the regulatory burden. The result, she added, was that…

  • ICE flags need for Europe to double green investment

    ICE flags need for Europe to double green investment

    Investments to modernise energy and transport must double by the end of the decade to reach 2030 climate targets, the EU has been warned. According to the Institute for Climate Economics (ICE), which has released the European Climate Investment Deficit report, the bloc lacks what it calls a “consistent tool” to ensure monitoring of the…